Well, my body is back from Iceland, but my spirit is definitely still lingering over there quite a bit. I will have to force myself out of “stun mode” soon and get back to the real world here in Southeast Ohio.
Basically, I seem to have gotten back into flatpicking arpeggio/chord-melody style with a whole different feel than ever before — offering a true alternative to my typical fingerpicking style which has become like a default style for me. Here are some of the amazing advantages of flatpicking that I see right away (they were way too blurry and ill-defined in the past):
1.) Flatpicking seems to let me generate more melodic LINES than fingerpicking. I play in a more linear fashion when I have a flatpick in my paws.
2.) I’m always playing more focused — playing LESS — with a flatpick than with fingerpicks. I think I still am in the overwhelmed-child mode with the fingerpicking: so amazed at the ridiculous possibilities that I go out and do as much as I can all the time.
3.) Flatpicking doesn’t seem to sacrifice the independence of a two-part polyphonic texture (during the very brief interludes in which I am able to really be present enough to manage two discrete lines simultaneously!!!). Even though I don’t often fingerpick in syncopated-melody-over-alternating-bass style much, I used to think that there was something in my fingerstyle playing that made for instant, easy polyphony — or maybe “almost-polyphony” because I’m not talking about it in a strict academic sense — but my flatpicking creates a sparser, and perhaps more LINEAR two-part texture probably more often than the fingerpicking. Curious and intriguing.
4.) Not too long ago, I was worried about all the alternating pick directions that I have to keep constantly in mind while flatpicking, and how fingerpicking is so automatic and no-brainer-esque. Well, if I just shut up the thinking, worrying mind and get to some flatpicking, it all seems to take care of itself. ANSWER: shut off brain and play music!
5.) Dynamics and timbral color seems to be MUCH, MUCH more powerful and yet more intimate and subtle at the same time with a flatpick. With 4 fingerpicks on, I can’t get anywheres near the place where the strings come off the bridge (Mr. BITE! in Neal Hellman’s classic terminology), nor can I get very far towards the Mr. MELLOW places at the 14th fret, without clicking too much on the fingerboard itself. The flatpick and its various hardnesses, stiffnesses, and materials allow worlds more color and dynamics to be coaxed from the dulcimer.
6.) I used to think that there was something about my fingerpicking that allowed me to get into a baroque basso-continuo style — something that wouldn’t be possible with a flatpick. NOT SO! After fingerpicking through this progression, which I learned from a chant CD I recently purchased:
Bm / / / | / / / / | D / / / | / / / / | G / / / | D / / / | A7 / / / | / / / / ||
….and getting some wonderful, but decidedly non-baroque results, I tried flatpicking melodies-through-chords, and I could not believe how much of a driving, relentless, continuo-esque jam I was able to create right on the spot.
I may try and post some tab at some point so you can try some of these things yourself. It’s really kind of hard to explain in words.
All the Best,
Jerry